Guides · Deposit disputes

Deposit dispute evidence: what wins with the adjudicator

Adjudicators decide on paper. The side with a signed check-in, a prompt and detailed check-out, dated photographs and itemised costs usually wins, and the burden of proof is on the landlord.

By ARX Algorithms, makers of SnagAudit · Updated 26 October 2026

The short answer

In a tenancy deposit dispute in England, an adjudicator from the deposit scheme (the Deposit Protection Service, mydeposits or the Tenancy Deposit Scheme) reads the evidence both sides upload and decides how the deposit is split. Nobody visits the property. Because the deposit is the tenant's money, the landlord or agent has to prove each deduction. The evidence all three schemes ask for is the same: a check-in inventory signed by the tenant, a check-out report, dated photographs or video, invoices, receipts or quotes, the tenancy agreement, and the written correspondence.

The evidence checklist

EvidenceWhy it matters
Check-in inventory, signed by the tenantThe baseline. The DPS says the adjudicator "will use the inventories to compare the property condition at the beginning and end of the tenancy".
Check-out reportShows what changed. TDS has said a detailed check-out report carries more evidential weight than an invoice.
Dated photographs or videoThe DPS asks for date-stamped photographs or video that are good quality and clearly show the damage.
Invoices, receipts, estimates and quotesProve the cost is reasonable. The DPS asks contractors to itemise costs by type of work; mydeposits says a quote counts even if the work has not been done.
Proof of an item's age and costNeeded to apportion a replacement fairly. Without it, TDS says an adjudicator is likely to assume a medium-quality item.
Signed tenancy agreementShows what the tenant agreed to, such as garden upkeep or cleaning.
CorrespondenceThe DPS says it helps establish a timeline of events.

Photographs that stand up

The schemes' guidance on photographs is specific:

For video, note the time in the footage where each issue appears, so the adjudicator can find it quickly. Check the upload limits: the DPS allows up to 40 MB per upload and mydeposits has a 20 MB per-file limit.

What weakens a case

Deadlines and timelines

SchemeKey dates
Deposit Protection Service (custodial)Both parties have 14 calendar days from the DPS's email to submit evidence. Pre-adjudication assessment takes up to seven days; the adjudicator then has up to 28 calendar days. The DPS says the process can take up to six weeks, and payment follows in 3 to 5 working days.
mydeposits (insured)The tenant must request resolution within three calendar months of moving out. The landlord pays the disputed amount within 10 working days of notification and has 20 working days from the initial notification to submit evidence; the tenant then has three working days to comment. The adjudicator decides within 28 calendar days.
mydeposits (custodial)Resolution can start after one full round of negotiation. Both parties confirm final evidence within five working days. A case assessor reviews within 20 working days, and an adjudicator decides within 28 calendar days if needed.
Tenancy Deposit SchemeTDS's head of dispute resolution has said a dispute can be submitted within three months of the end date of the tenancy.

Whatever the scheme, once you agree an amount the deposit must be returned within 10 days of agreement.

A worked example

A published mydeposits case shows how the evidence decides the outcome. The landlord claimed £1,050 from a £1,200 deposit: £900 to redecorate several rooms and £150 to fill holes. The check-in recorded the walls in excellent condition; the check-out and photographs showed scuffs, pencil drawings and twelve fixture holes. The adjudicator awarded the £150 for filling in full, as a repair. The décor was about four years into a five-year life after a tenancy of over three and a half years, so only 20% of the £900, £180, was awarded. The tenant got £720 of the disputed £1,050 back. Without the check-in description and the photos, the landlord would have struggled to get even that.

Building the evidence as you go

The strongest evidence is created at the time, not assembled afterwards. SnagAudit keeps photographs inside the app rather than in the camera roll, stamps each with the date and time (and location if you allow it), and records a hash at capture so it can be shown not to have been altered. Signatures record the signer's name, role, time and device. At check-out, each check-in item and photograph comes forward, so the PDF shows before and after side by side, with a schedule of proposed deductions. Acceptance of any evidence is always the adjudicator's decision, so keep your original files.

Related: end of tenancy check-out checklist and property inventory checklist.

Sources

Questions

Who has to prove a deposit deduction?

The landlord or agent. The deposit remains the tenant's money until the landlord shows a deduction is justified, so the adjudicator looks for evidence supporting each claim.

Are photographs enough to win a deposit dispute?

Rarely on their own. mydeposits says photographs should not be relied on exclusively. They are strongest when they are dated and sit alongside a signed check-in inventory and a detailed check-out report.

How long do I have to submit evidence to the DPS?

Both parties have 14 calendar days from the Deposit Protection Service's email to submit their evidence.

How long does a deposit dispute take?

The Deposit Protection Service says up to six weeks for custodial disputes, though often quicker. mydeposits' adjudicators decide within 28 calendar days of a case being prepared.

Do quotes count if the work has not been done?

Yes. mydeposits says an estimate or quote counts as evidence and the work does not have to be completed for it to be considered, but the cost must be reasonable and proportionate.